Ethiopia’s jailing of Zone 9 bloggers has a chilling effect on freedom of expression
Group calling for greater rights and democracy faces terrorism charges as Addis Ababa becomes wary of media that criticises ruling government
Yikanu Yelma mum Shimeles
Yikanu Yelma, mother of Ethiopian blogger Soliyana Shimeles, had her home searched after Shimeles was charged in absentia for her role in the Zone 9 blog. Human rights and press-freedom advocates say the arrests demonstrate a crackdown on critics of the government. Photograph: Simona Foltyn/Washington Post
Simona Foltyn for the Washington Post
Monday 27 April 2015 08.58 BST
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via Email Share on LinkedIn Share on Google+
They met online in 2010 while raising money for charity: nine young, university-educated Ethiopian professionals. Eventually, they decided to launch a blog about social and civic issues in Africa’s second-most-populous nation.
“Initially, it was not about political activism or about criticising the government. It was to connect with like-minded people,” said Soliyana Shimeles, 28, one of the founders of the blog Zone 9.
Today, six of the bloggers are in jail facing terrorism charges in what human rights and press-freedom advocates call an example of an alarming crackdown on government critics.
Analysis ‘Ethiopia’s media crackdown is bad news for Africa’
Without a free press in Addis Ababa, Africans are being locked out of the important decisions being made in their de facto capital, writes Simon Allison
The Zone 9 bloggers are accused of “creating serious risk to the safety or health of the public” under the country’s controversial anti-terrorism law passed in 2009. The charges further allege the bloggers were linked to Ginbot 7, an opposition movement based abroad that the government labelled a terrorist group in 2011. The bloggers have pleaded not guilty.
Their attorney, Ameha Mekonnen, has complained that the charges offer few particulars. The trial began at the end of March but was adjourned until after the national elections in May. If convicted, the defendants could be sentenced to death.
Members of Ethiopia’s online community say the case has had a chilling effect on freedom of expression. The US State Department criticised the Ethiopian high court’s decision in January to proceed with the trial, saying that it “undermines a free and open media environment”.
Ethiopia has been an important US ally in the fight against al-Shabaab, the Somalia-based Islamist group. But while Ethiopia is a multi-party democracy on paper, its ruling party controls all but one seat in parliament.
The “Zone9ers” hail from a relatively privileged urban educated class in one of the world’s poorest countries. Only 2% of Ethiopian households have access to the internet in this Horn of Africa nation, whose state-run, telecommunication infrastructure ranks among the continent’s least developed.
The nine bloggers – three journalists, a human rights lawyer and professionals working in business, government and academia – met online while raising money for the family of an Ethiopian maid who died while working in Lebanon. They called their blog Zone 9, a term said to be used by political prisoners in Addis Ababa’s Kaliti jail to refer to an outside world they viewed as equally shackled by the lack of civil liberties.
The ruling party has become wary of media they cannot directly control
The bloggers, part of a generation that came of age after a Marxist dictatorship was toppled in 1991, said they wanted to raise awareness about political and social issues in a society disengaged from civic matters. Their blog posts called on young Ethiopians to demand rights set out in the constitution and to put into practice the democracy the government had promised.
“I used to think our discussions could transform our audiences into the kind of society we want. I was very naive,” said a close friend of the bloggers, who spoke on condition of anonymity for fear of reprisals.
Over the past decade, the Ethiopian government, which controls the country’s main media outlets, has displayed varying degrees of appetite for free political discourse. National elections in 2005 were preceded by a relatively open climate, allowing the opposition to win a third of the seats in the 547-member parliament. But after the vote, there were mass arrests of opposition politicians and student protesters. In the years that followed, several newspapers and magazines were shut down.
“The ruling party has become wary of media they cannot directly control,” said Daniel Berhane, an Ethiopian blogger and editor of the current-affairs website Horn Affairs, referring to the Zone 9 case.
Yet many Ethiopians believe that the group’s blog posts, which had an average of 18,000 readers in a country of 94 million, were not what landed them behind bars. The “Zone9ers” attended events organised by international human rights organisations. The Ethiopian government has frequently been critical of such groups, accusing them of being politicised. The bloggers also attended training sessions held abroad and in Ethiopia on internet security, which may have upset a government that has been accused of surveillance of its critics’ online activity.
The bloggers visited jailed dissidents, including prominent journalist Eskinder Nega and opposition member Andualem Aragie, to express their support.
Shimeles’s mother, Yikanu Yelma, said the young blogger drew inspiration from her father, who had been jailed in 1977 for opposing the communist regime. “She used to say: my Dad contributed something during his time. I need to contribute something during my time,” Yelma recalled in an interview in Addis Ababa.
The Zone 9 bloggers used their real names online “to be accountable for what we say”, Shimeles, who has been charged in absentia, explained in a Skype interview from Washington, where she has applied for political asylum.
Ironically, the arrests may have drawn attention to a group that previously had little influence
On 25 April last year, six of the nine bloggers were arrested. Shimeles and another member of the group happened to be abroad, while a third participant fled the country. Three independent journalists are facing charges alongside the Zone 9 bloggers.
The trial has been adjourned repeatedly. The bloggers’ attorney said none of the evidence presented thus far implicate his clients in crimes.
The government has rejected criticism of its handling of the case by western governments and human rights groups. It asserts the bloggers are on trial for attempting to sabotage the state. “None of them were arrested for what they wrote,” said Ganenu Asefa, an adviser at the government office for communication affairs.
Ethiopia’s government has achieved double-digit growth in the past five years, driven largely by state intervention in the economy and massive public investments. But the independence of its judicial system was rated 2.9 out of a best possible score of 7 in a recent report by the World Economic Forum. The ruling Ethiopian People’s Revolutionary Democratic Front dismisses criticism about the political system.
“We want our democratic values to grow from within. We don’t want anyone to export them to us,” said Dina Mufti, spokesperson at the ministry of foreign affairs.
Family and friends of the bloggers say that their arrests, ironically, may have drawn attention to a group that previously had little influence.
“My sister often says that they have done more for their cause while in prison,” says Fisseha Fantahun, the brother of one jailed blogger, 30-year-old Mahilet Fantahun, who had worked as a data analyst at the ministry of health.
But others say the trial has been effective in sending a chilling message. Many members of the online community now use aliases or have abandoned blogging. A friend who regularly visits the jailed bloggers said they have voiced disappointment at the void left by their arrests. “Their ideas were not taken forward by anyone. It’s very sad,” he said. He has retreated from the online community.
This article appeared in Guardian Weekly, which incorporates material from the Washington Post
More features Topics
Ethiopia Africa Freedom of speech Press freedom Newspapers & magazines More…